Friday, November 25, 2011

2011-2012 ITG Ultimate Memorabilia 11th Edition Review

It's taken a while, but I finally get to review ITG's Ultimate Memorabilia 11!  I would like to first thank Youtube user tvtvrain (Miles) for helping me get the cards necessary for this review.  Without him, this review either would not have happened or would have been even more delayed.  Please go to his Youtube channel and check him out.  Amazing, amazing stuff there... and he's a big ITG fan.  Now, let's see what nastiness ITG brings to the table with their uber high-end release.


Base Card Design -
Each standard pack of UM11 comes with three cards - the first of which is the base card.  Even though there is no memorabilia or autograph on these cards, they are encased in ITG's special card holder.  Like all ITG encapsulated cards, the inset at the top gives information about what the card you have is: the product name/year, type, player, number of copies, and number in the production run.  For UM11, ITG chose to go with a very basic base card design.  The card is only two color tones - white and silver.  The artwork looks great, but to me the card is quite bland.  The silver ink is too close to the white background and gives the cards a very washed out feel.  It just doesn't stand out.  I would have preferred a bolder approach - perhaps a different choice than silver or to just have the player image in full color.  As it stands, what sticks out to me most is the foil green label above the card.


The back of the base cards are nice.  I definitely like the thin silver border over the thick one on the front - it's pretty classy.  Now I don't mind the back's use of silver ink like I did on the front.  It's very clean and regal, and works great with the paragraph.  I enjoy that the card features a lengthy paragraph of information about the player.  These cards do no contain any stat lines, but often these super high-end cards do not carry them, or even if they do, very minimally.

All the standard silver versions of the base cards are limited to only 62.  Yes, these cards are scarce!  In packs you may find other versions of the base cards such as gold ones or even 1 of 1 original artwork versions of the base cards.

Base Card Design Score:
6.5/10

Inserts/Game-Used/Autos -
Similar to other high-end releases, this is where the meat and potatoes of the product are.  Aside from the base card, the other two cards within the pack are an autograph card and a memorabilia card.  Some cards will feature an autograph along with a memorabilia piece.  And every card will have an extremely low production run.


Shown above is a standard autographed card you might find in UM11.  It's of goalie legend  Dominik Hasek.  This card is numbered 8 of 9.  The design of this card is top notch.  In the past I,  along with other collectors, have had issues with how ITG designed their cards.  Not here.  This Ultimate Legend Autograph looks great from top to bottom.  The color scheme is very modern.  I love the shades of grey that ITG employs here.  There is something very industrial about it.  The single red border of the left hand side of the card is a great accent.  The lines flow well and every piece of the card is perfect where it is, from the picture, to the framed autograph, to the logos.  This card looks just as good as anything coming out of Upper Deck and Panini.  Excellent job here ITG.  This is the way modern cards look!


This Stan Mikita jersey card is typical of a jersey found in UM11.  It's probably the most basic type you will find in the product.  Even though it's just a single jersey swatch, it is still limited to only 24 copies, and contains a good-sized chunk of jersey.  What I love about this card is that the back indicates that the jersey did indeed come from a game-used Chicago Blackhawks jersey that Mikita wore.  It's such a bold statement to make in the current state of card production!  So many other companies use event-worn pieces in their cards, but ITG boldly tells the collector that their pieces are from actual games.  In terms of this card design, it's not the greatest, but it still looks good.  It's lines are reminiscent of SPx without all the foil highlights.


Now here's an interesting idea for a card - encapsulate a special moment in time.  This card highlights Dave Andreychuk's 600th goal.  He scored his 600th on November 23, 2002 on Corey Schwab.  The card has a piece of Andreychuk's stick and a swatch of Schwab's jersey.  I think this is a wonderful idea, but the execution of it could have been better in my opinion.  I like the fact that there is a picture of Andreychuk, because I know in the past ITG would put out cards with no player image on the front.  But I think it would have been even better to also include Schwab.  Perhaps turn the card horizontally and make it seem like a dual between the two players - I don't know - just an idea.  The best would be to have an image of the goal being scored.  Unfortunately ITG does not have an NHL license so probably getting a photo of the actual 600th goal would have been out of the question.  And that is really too bad.


One pack in every 10-box case of UM11 will be a hot pack.  These packs will contain some of the best patches from the product.  I was fortunate enough to pull a hot pack in the one pack that I bought of UM11.  Pretty lucky, but these cards look great and are limited to only 9 for modern players - 4 for vintage.  I think including these hot packs as a special surprise for collectors was a great idea.  ITG did a wonderful job of changing up the design to really represent what a hot patch should be like: RED HOT!  Changing the label to indicate the heat was spot on.  Over the entire production run of UM11 there were only 150 hot packs produced.

There are many more amazing things to be found in UM11.  The first that comes to mind are the 1 of 1 Ultimate Emblems cards.  If you don't know what those are do yourself a favor and see if you can find some pictures of them on the internet.  They will blow your mind.

Inserts/Game-Used/Autos Score:
9/10

Overall Rating -
ITG's Ultimate Memorabilia 11th Edition is not a product for everyone simply for the fact that most people will not be able to afford a box.  Even one pack of three cards is significantly higher than a standard box of hockey cards.  But for those who want the best quality of memorabilia and the chance at some truly ridiculous game-used pieces... this is the product to get.

The best way of experiencing UM11 is to get a box or to get boxes of it.  Purchasing just one pack is a pretty risky gamble, but would suffice for just a taste of the product.  For those who can afford it, UM11 is a product that delivers great thrills when being opened.  It certainly ranks right up with the Cup and Dominion.

This year's Ultimate Memorabilia offering has improved in the design department, and I think this will attract more and more collectors to it.  It's not all the way there yet, but it's so close!  I'm really pleased to see ITG continue to step up their card design.  Particularly impressive was the Hasek autograph card shown above.  More cards like this will definitely catch the eye of collectors who value not only the quality of the memorabilia, but also of the way the cards look.

Overall Rating:
9/10
(not an average)

I pulled a hot pack!

36 comments:

  1. Hi Luke.
    I personaly think that ITG 11th is a very nice product this year. it is very expensive but i think that it is worth it if you look at what you can pull.

    YT name is- Priceforthewin

    ReplyDelete
  2. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Wow, crazy hot pack. ITG put some really nice patches in here. Seems that a lot of the cards are low numbered so that's always a nice perk. Quite expensive but has some crazy cards in it! Thanks for the review!

    YT name- stankyyankee95

    ReplyDelete
  4. Great review! I think that ITG put some crazy cards in this product! I love the designs of almost everything (except the base cards). It is very expensive and I will probably never end up buying something like this, but if you have the money to purchase I think it is definatly worth it. Overall I give it a 9.5/10.

    Thanks for the contest!

    -Dakota15x

    ReplyDelete
  5. I really like UM11. The hits you are guaranteed are always really nice and if you compared a box of UM to the CUP, i would chose the UM because i think it holds better value, and there are better and more cards to recieve in a box of UM. I love how the cards come in a graded packaging, they must hold better value because of those packages alone, making sure the cards are mint.

    -CanucksCollector

    ReplyDelete
  6. I am not a huge fan of this product. I do not like the design of the cards but I think you get your moneys worth because they are all low numbered.

    Thanks for all the contests.

    Kylevdb

    ReplyDelete
  7. in my opinion, ITG is quite an expensive product...the base cards could use a little more colour cuz it's black and white for players still in the NHL...it'd look better if it's white and black for retired players only and the autos and jerseys aren't half bad. the hot patches are great though and worth buying...too bad the chances are low...pretty solid review though and thanks again for yet another comntest, luke

    gonucksgo33(YT)

    ReplyDelete
  8. Hey whats up broski...got a chance to bust a ton of this stuff at the expo...thanks to cloutsnchara of course...saw some amazing pulls...my youtube is poisonthewealhymofo...i just wanted to say i still have some of my um 11 in hand...the base cards aren't as good as years before although they are numbered lower....INTERESTING FACT...all the base cards accept one are numbered to 62...tony esposito is numbered to 63...but in all honesty....this product is better than the cup hit wise. you get 5 base cards per BOX...and 10 hits per box..aside from dominon this product is product of the year...

    poisonthewealhymofo

    ReplyDelete
  9. i always liked the itg ultimate, too bad it is so expensive.. but i aleays try to get some card of my pc players.
    Really cool that the base cards are limited to 62, and the memorbilia cards are sick..
    Great rewiew as alaways, and thanks for the contest..

    Roggan47

    ReplyDelete
  10. I would love to get a box of ITG ultimate but like you said the price is just so high most people cant spend that much on a box of hockey cards, which is unfortunate. For the review though I definitely like what they did with the hot packs, like you said in your review adding that flaming border was a awesome idea! The base card design does like a little blah but every other card is just great! So overall, this is an amazing product but unfortunately I probably will not be getting any in the near future.

    Thanks for the contest!

    HabsFan771

    ReplyDelete
  11. Hey Luke
    UM11 Is awesome! Even though I definitely couldn't afford it.
    I think the review was very solid, I agree about the base being 6.5/10 because they are not the best lol. Overall I would give it 8.5/10

    Thanks! CapsPuck8

    ReplyDelete
  12. I think the base cards are really boring, the designs of the cards to me are ok, I would rather buy a nox of the cup, it seems to give you more bang for your bucksssssss.
    Thrashersdude

    ReplyDelete
  13. I agree when you say that ITG has stepped it up this year. Card design is key and I believe they have improved on that this year. Your review was spot on as always. Keep up the great reviews. :)

    - 91HockeyCards

    ReplyDelete
  14. I REALY LIKE THIS PRODUCT
    BUT SOMETIMES U GET KIND OF SHUTOUT
    THE CARDS LOOK SICK BUT THE BASE CARDS ARE OKAY
    IM SJOVECHKINFAN
    PS.NICE REVIEW

    ReplyDelete
  15. I like the design of the hits but the base cards are ugly. i would get some but it's too much. phxfan19

    ReplyDelete
  16. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  17. hey Luke, I think ultimate is a great product but I thing in the end the cup has much more potential in hits that ITG. Overall though I still think this product is very cool. I to do not like the base cards that much, but in my opinion the others cards have awesome designs. Like you said I couldn't afford it ( I can barely even afford a 11 12 artifacts) but it is still an awesome product.

    youtube username: teeheekid1

    ReplyDelete
  18. Itg ultimate is usually on of my favourite product every year.. i dont know why but for some reason this year im just not a huge fan. I would still probably go out and buy a pack to see if i could pull one of the huge hit that are out there. But i doubt i would be dropping 700 on a box. Great review and thanks for the contest.

    Youtube Username-Mrsp0rtsfreak

    ReplyDelete
  19. ultimate is a go big or go home product
    nice hot pack,MrRedWingsFan131

    ReplyDelete
  20. I like the idea of Ultimate but I'm not a huge fan of the price. To me it seems like to big of a gamble to make a good return off the cards you get. The hot pack you got was really cool but its still very high risk.
    Thanks Luke
    youtube handle=CanesOnTheBrains

    ReplyDelete
  21. Let's get real here. Those are the worst base cards ever made in the history of sports card collecting.
    6.5? lol

    ReplyDelete
  22. You have the opportunity to get good old players memorabilias and nice autos. This is cool, but I think it is way too costly for what it is... I prefer getting legends or present players. Last thing, I like to touch the patch and the jersey, in ITG they come in a little box that won't let me do this. I would like to get this as a gift, but I really don't have the money to afford this and I would buy Dominion before this...
    lfcmontreal

    ReplyDelete
  23. hey luke
    the product is good but really expensive.
    HockeyAndrey - youtube

    LOVE your vids

    ReplyDelete
  24. hey luke, i feel that um 11/12 is very nice looking like always! i think that you will get your moneys worth if u buy a box or a pack. the only down side is that it is really expensive. but like i said you will get your moneys worth almost every time!

    -THEHOCKEYCARDS

    ReplyDelete
  25. I think that this product is really nice looking, but it's waaaay to expensive, at my local card shop, they sell the box for 801$. It's just crazy. I think you get your money back most of the time, but I wouldn't buy a box

    thanks
    12iginlacalgary12 on youtube

    ReplyDelete
  26. I really do like this product, ITG has once again impressed me with the release of Ultimate 11th Edition, just too bad that I can't afford it haha. Each pack will have something cool and is definitely worth the price. What I love about ITG is that they are able to obtain vintage memoribilia from hockey greats such as Maurice Richard, Bobby Orr, Bobby Hull and put them into products. It really would be awesome to pull a card with a piece of history.

    Hockeycardfan1000 on youtube

    ReplyDelete
  27. ITG isnt my favourite prduct because I dont really like the fact that they are all in the graded cases. But I do love the cards themselves, ITG is my favourite manufacturer of cards.

    Wilsonethan6 Youtube

    ReplyDelete
  28. i would want the product because it is nice to have memmerabilia in 1 pack or all numbered cards.. i like the prouduct because chances 1 of a million times there will be a card damaged or because its hi end

    - grandycanman14

    ReplyDelete
  29. ITG ultimate mem is a product I usually enjoy watching. However it is not a product that i would ever try to break because i wouldnt be able to afford the entire thing and in 1 pack there are only 3 cards. The price for a pack is like 200+? In my eyes i see it is a hit or miss unless you buy the entire box. Base cards are okay, but not the best. Having a base in every pack to me is a downer because your other 2 hits coming up will either be GOOD or BAD. You could get a real nice auto or stick pieces ect... but it is really risky. I would rather buy the cards separately than break a pack or box. Don't get me wrong though there are AMAZING cards in this brand. The good thing about ITG is that they bring back old players. Players who are dead, in hof, retired, legends ect.. that is what makes itg so popular especially ith this product. Ill give it a 8/10 :)

    - MrSport4life

    ReplyDelete
  30. This is a product that I would never be able to break at the price point. I think the mem cards in this product are very nice and ITG did a great job with the pieces. The base cards are average but for the price I don't think they should have included the base cards in each pack. I like how each card is casing though!

    -RetailRippers

    ReplyDelete
  31. I think this product is a bit pricey. For the price tag i would rather buy a tin of Upper Deck the Cup because i like being able to see and hold the card,but on the other side i do like the fact that they cant get damaged and will always be in mint condition. The base could use more color and more design. I also like how they have a big variety in memorabilia and autograph cards you can get. I give this a 7/10.

    - Bassplayer1801

    ReplyDelete
  32. Personally, I think this product is vastly overpriced. I feel their is most often much more value in a pack of Dominion or Cup. Also, I'd rather my cards came unslabbed, as I want to be able to touch and feel the cards, and the history behind them.

    - ethannyk

    ReplyDelete
  33. Wow, some really great highend stuff in that product. You do great reviews, and I appreciate the constant contests. Amazing.
    -Skroeker24

    ReplyDelete
  34. ya your review was great as always .. i love this product but as i am a young collector the price is way to high!!

    - reistv11

    ReplyDelete
  35. This his a true high end card product. The inserts are crazy. Too bad I don't have the money to buy myself a box. Nice review, you are very interesting. Even for a french speaking man.

    ReplyDelete
  36. CONTEST IS NOW OVER! But feel free to continue leaving comments about UM11!

    ReplyDelete